Should you vibe code your freight forwarding software?

by | Industry

A few years ago, the build-versus-buy debate was one of the most common technology questions in logistics. Should freight forwarders invest in commercial software designed for the industry? Or build something themselves that perfectly matches their workflows?

For many companies, the answer was simple. They built their own tools. Often, it started with a spreadsheet or database maintained by someone in the office who happened to be particularly good with computers. Let’s call him Roger.

Roger built macros, dashboards, and tracking sheets. Over time, those tools grew into a system the entire company depended on. Eventually, however, those systems often reached a breaking point. As businesses scaled and supply chains became more complex, homegrown software struggled to keep up.

Now, a new technology trend is reviving the same question in a different form. The latest buzzword in the software world is “vibe coding.” With modern AI tools, developers and non-developers alike can describe the software they want in plain language while an AI generates the underlying code.

This shift is happening fast. In fact, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella recently said that roughly 30% of the company’s code is now written by AI. For freight forwarders exploring new technology, this raises an intriguing possibility. If AI can build software so quickly, should logistics companies start building their own systems again? The answer, however, is a lot more nuanced than it might first appear.

Why Vibe Coding Is So Hot Right Now

AI-assisted development has dramatically lowered the barrier to building software.

Tools like GitHub Copilot, Cursor, Claude Code, and Codeium can generate code snippets, troubleshoot bugs, and even create full applications from written prompts. New platforms such as Lovable, Bolt.new, and Vercel v0 promise to generate working interfaces and workflows with minimal manual coding.

For logistics companies that have always wanted software tailored precisely to their operations, it’s an exciting development. The appeal is easy to understand.

  • Speed: AI can produce working prototypes far faster than traditional development cycles.
  • Customization: Freight forwarders often have unique operational workflows, specialized documentation processes, or regional compliance requirements that generic software may not immediately accommodate.
  • Experimentation: AI tools allow teams to quickly test new ideas without committing months of development resources.

In other words, our dear Roger now has a powerful new assistant. But, there’s an huge distinction between generating code and taking ownership of a mission-critical software system.

 

The Myth That AI Makes Software Effortless

The phrase “vibe coding” suggests a casual process where developers simply describe an idea and let AI handle the rest. In reality, building reliable software still requires significant expertise.

AI pioneer Andrew Ng has cautioned that the term itself can be misleading, stating, “Working with AI to generate software is not effortless. It’s an intellectually demanding process that still requires real engineering skill.”

AI can indeed accelerate the development process, but it does not remove the need for architectural design, security reviews, testing, or long-term maintenance.

This distinction becomes especially important when software moves from experimentation to operational infrastructure. Freight forwarding software is not simply a dashboard or reporting tool. It often sits at the center of a company’s operations, connecting shipments, customers, accounting systems, compliance workflows, and carrier integrations.

The real question is no longer how quickly it can be built, but rather who owns it once it becomes mission critical.

 

The Hidden Responsibilities of Owning Logistics Software

When companies decide to build their own system, even with AI assistance, they take on responsibilities that go far beyond generating code.

Software ownership includes long-term commitments such as:

  • Maintaining integrations with carriers, customs portals, and partners
  • Updating workflows as regulations change
  • Monitoring system security
  • Scaling infrastructure as shipment volumes grow
  • Training employees on new functionality
  • Troubleshooting operational issues when the system breaks

These tasks require ongoing investment and expertise. Even companies that successfully build a first version of their software often discover that maintaining it becomes the real challenge. And when AI-generated code enters the picture, additional risks can emerge.

The Security Problem With AI-Generated Code

One of the most frequently cited concerns about AI-generated software is security.

Research evaluating AI-produced code has found that 45% of AI-generated code samples contain security vulnerabilities.

Common issues include insecure dependencies, missing validation checks, and exposed credentials. For many consumer applications, these vulnerabilities may be manageable. For freight forwarding systems, however, the stakes are significantly higher.

Logistics platforms routinely handle:

  • financial transactions
  • shipment documentation
  • customs filings
  • customer data
  • operational workflows tied to physical cargo

Any weakness in those systems can have serious consequences. Code may appear to work correctly while still introducing hidden risks.

 

When AI-Built Systems Become Fragile

Another concern raised by developers is the long-term maintainability of AI-generated systems.

Because AI tools can generate large volumes of code quickly, teams may deploy applications without fully understanding how the system works internally. This creates what some engineers call “invisible technical debt.”

The CEO of Cursor, one of the fastest-growing AI coding platforms, has warned companies about relying too heavily on AI-generated systems without understanding them. “If you close your eyes and don’t look at the code and have AIs build things with shaky foundations, as you add another floor, and another floor, things start to kind of crumble,” he stated. 

That analogy resonates strongly in logistics. Freight forwarding systems often evolve over years as companies add integrations, compliance workflows, and operational automations. A system that works well in its early stages can become increasingly fragile as complexity grows.

 

The Real Question Isn’t Build or Buy

For freight forwarders evaluating AI tools, the conversation should not revolve around whether AI can build software.

The more important question is what role AI should play within a company’s technology strategy.

AI can accelerate development.
It can automate tasks.
It can even help generate new features.

But most logistics companies are not software companies.

Their success lies in moving freight, serving customers, and navigating complex global trade environments. Running a large-scale software platform requires an entirely different set of capabilities.

 

Combining AI Innovation With Decades of Logistics Experience

At Magaya, we share the same excitement about the possibilities that AI brings to the logistics industry. The possibilities are truly endless! 

AI has the potential to make freight operations more intelligent, more responsive, and more automated than ever before. From assisting with documentation and workflows to surfacing insights from operational data, the opportunities are significant.

That’s why Magaya has already begun using AI across the organization to improve internal processes, accelerate development, and help our teams work more efficiently. From supporting product innovation to enhancing operational workflows behind the scenes, these tools are helping us move faster while maintaining the reliability our customers depend on.

Plus, we’ve introduced several AI-powered capabilities into the platform and continue to actively develop new ones. Our AI development approach is deliberate. Rather than experimenting in isolation, we develop these capabilities in close collaboration with our customers, focusing on specific operational challenges where AI can deliver real value.

It’s the best of both worlds: you gain access to the speed and innovation that AI makes possible, while still benefiting from the stability and expertise of a commercial logistics platform.

Magaya brings 25 years of experience working with thousands of freight forwarders and logistics providers. Over those decades, the platform has evolved through real-world operational feedback, regulatory changes, and the day-to-day realities of running global supply chains. That collective experience shapes how new technology is introduced.

When AI features are added to the platform, they are supported by the broader system architecture, security standards, integrations, and development teams required to maintain mission-critical software.

The goal is to apply new technology in ways that genuinely improve how freight forwarders operate, while ensuring the systems they depend on remain reliable, secure, and scalable.

Ready to digitize and modernize your freight forwarding operations?

See how Magaya can help.